In a cynical photo-op in New Orleans, today, President Bush will use the backdrop of a local charter school to promote his "No Child Left Behind" policy. If anything, the disaster of hurricane Katrina represents the willingness of the Bush...

>>Twitter this post!

My Photo
Jeffrey Feldman, Editor-in-Chief
Frameshop, 03/01/2007

In a cynical photo-op in New Orleans, today, President Bush will use the backdrop of a local charter school to promote his "No Child Left Behind" policy.

If anything, the disaster of hurricane Katrina represents the willingness of the Bush administration not only to leave children behind--literally, leave them behind in rising floodwaters--but to then blame those children's predicament on their lack of education.

The announcement for a local protest planned, today, frames the situation best.  Even before Bush failed in the face of Katrina, his policies were already ripping the roof of the public school system.

From Humid City:


    2319 VALENCE ST.
    (Near Freret and Napoleon)

    New Orleans Needs Federal Aid, Not Presidential Photo-Ops.
    Mr. President: Katrina Survivors Do Not Welcome You, We Rebuke You!

    We live in a devastated city and you are a big part of the reason why it sill sits in ruins. Your administration has abandoned our children by savaging their public schools. Your administration has tortured our working class people by refusing to reopen the city’s public housing developments. And your administration is fully complicit in placing our uninsured in harms way by ruthlessly pursuing the privatization of local public healthcare in the aftermath of Katrina. And, finally your administration is guilty of sending our sons and daughters of to war for oil and empire just when we need them most to help us rebuild our community.

    Mr. President, we, Katrina Survivors all, do not welcome you to our city, we rebuke you!

    Sponsored by Survivors Village, United Front For Affordable Housing.
    (504) 587-0080

Keep in mind that one of the major frames that Bush and the authoritarian right cling to about Katrina is that the disaster was a "failure of citizenship."

As Newt Gingrich put it his 2006 speech at Johns Hopkins:

The last great domestic challenge I think is the fact that we have large structured government institutions that simply don’t work.  You saw some of this with what happened in New Orleans and Katrina.  The fact is, in Katrina, government failed.  The federal government failed.  The state of Louisiana failed.  The city of New Orleans failed.  And for 22,000 citizens in the lower 9th ward, citizenship failed.  They literally did not have the education, the training, the habits of responsibility, or the capacity to get out of the way of a hurricane.  And so you have got to look at that experience and say how much do you have to change each of those four layers, so that if it happened again you didn’t have the same failure?

In Gingrich's logic--which has largely become GOP logic--the really real cause of the humanitarian disaster in New Orleans was not the failure of the federal government to mobilize its resources on behalf of citizens in need, but the failure of citizenship to work on behalf of citizens.

It is an odd rhetorical construction, but we see where he is heading.  Government should change, he is telling us, but  it should change by accelerating the destruction of government programs and public schools--moving faster to set up an authoritarian vision of a country where all government action is displaced by a vague notion of responsibility.

By touting "No Child Left Behind,"  today in New Orleans, Bush is really saying that the disaster in Katrina happend because his Utopian vision of free-market America was hampered--ergo, the people of New Orleans became victims instead of what they were supposed to be:  prepared citizens.

All of this, of course, glosses over the continuing cry of voices on the ground in Katrina--people who spend every waking moment of their lives rebuilding a city from scratch, only to be rewarded by a college flunky President who claims education is the key to getting ahead.

Education is important, no doubt. But it was not so much children who were left behind by the authoritarian conservative movement in this country in the decade before Katrina.  What was left behind--or rather thrown from the moving train--was the American principle that the purpose of government is to help individuals in situations where they cannot help themselves. 

Flood waters crashing through a levee system left in disrepair was precisely one of those moments where  individuals needed the collective strength and ability of their government to help them. 

President Bush should be ashamed of himself for promoting such a cynical ideology of personal responsibility in a city still reeling from the failures of his worldview and actions.

© 2007 Jeffrey Feldman, Frameshop

© Jeffrey Feldman 2007, Frameshop

>>Twitter this post!


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Frameshop: Bush to Tout "No Child Left Behind" in New Orleans:


blog comments powered by Disqus
Frameshop and all contents copyright © 2004-2009, Jeffrey Feldman. All rights reserved. Unless otherwise noted, content may not be reproduced without expressed written permission.